Wednesday, February 09, 2011

Stop the presses, I read another parenting book

At this stage in the parenting game, I rarely find parenting books I would recommend. Of course I still always recommend the Louise Bates Ames series of developmental books, but I've come to believe many of the parenting "experts" out there are really no different than parents like you and me, except they've written a book.

(All of this does NOT apply to researchers and people who study large populations and then write books with FACTS. I still recommend those.)

I recently read a book that I wished I had read the first year of Nate and Alex's life: "How She Really Does It: Secrets of Successful Stay-at-Work Moms." I would highly recommend this book to any working mom.

I refuse to get into any kind of working mom versus stay-at-home mom debate because I truly believe there are pros and cons to each option. I also believe it is a personal choice and my overriding opinion is that a happy, fulfilled mother is a good mother.

Yet our current society has placed such a strong emphasis on being a "perfect" mother - one who relishes all of the aspects of parenting (even the gross ones, like cleaning up vomit), one who smiles through the tantrums, one who makes homemade treats for every school holidays, one who never runs out of patience, one who cries when she drops off her kids and can't wait for the minute she picks them back up, and one who places their kids above everything else in their lives.

Sorry, that's not me. It never will be.

When I went back to work, I often heard snide comments like:
  • Oh that's too bad you have to be away from your babies so much.
  • Do you want someone else to raise your children?
  • Jon makes a lot of money so why do you work?
  • If you quit your job, you'd have so much more time to take care of sick kids/volunteer in the classroom/work out/pursue hobbies.
Each of these makes my blood boil because they are so judgmental of my CHOICE to work outside the home. Since the age of 18 (almost 20 years!) I have been working hard on my career and that didn't stop when I had kids. Yet it is totally fine in our culture to say things like the above to working moms, all of which I consider horribly rude and condescending of the choices I've made.

Back to my point... this book was AMAZING to me because it was the first book I've ever read that emphasizes the positives of being a working mom. It featured moms like me, moms who chose to continue their careers and try to balance their personal goals with raising children. I've always known that continuing to work has made me the best mom I can be, and it was so refreshing to hear it over and over in this book from other mothers.

None of this was new information to me, but I had so much guilt the first year because I didn't "fit the mold." All around me, I saw women quit their jobs because they didn't want to be away from their babies. I couldn't help but wonder what was wrong with me that I was missing that gene. I've resolved a lot of that guilt by now because I know it was the right choice, but this book would have made my road a little easier in the beginning. This book would have helped me see there are plenty of other moms out there like me.

Also if I had this book then, when someone said something judgmental about my choice to work, I would have had something to shove where the sun don't shine.

19 comments:

Beth said...

Nothing to add but a huge AMEN!!! I will be adding that book to my "to read" list.

Joanna said...

Another "Amen"!

JenFen said...

Sounds like a really interesting read. Does it talk about the unique challenges of working from home? Of course it will be another one my library system DOES NOT carry but I would love to read it.

And I made my choice and have always tried to be respectful of the choices other moms make. I 100% agree that a happy mom makes a better mom. I am sorry that anyone ever made you feel guilty for doing what you knew in your heart was right for you and your family. That just saddens me.

London said...

What's sad is that there is so much critism on both sides. As a sahm I often feel looked down upon as "being lazy" or unambitious. I often lose patience with both my kids, and I would totally NOT cry if I had to leave them both for the day!

Great post.

Stacey said...

I am a far more patient mother because I work. Homemade stuff? No guilt here over buying stuff instead!

Lee Anne said...

What a perfect post for me to read today! I am considering heading back to work and feeling lots of guilt both ways. I still can't believe people still judge mothers who choose to go back to work. I think you have to do what is best for you so that you can be a better mother. And if that means working then that is what you need to do! Will be looking for this book soon...

Mrs. Merriman said...

Here here!! I've added the book to my shopping cart as we speak! Thx, L :D

windycityvegan said...

FINALLY. I have so much to say a bout this, but I'm just going to leave it at w00t! Now I just need to find a positive sahf book for my husband to read, and quash *his* guilt about choosing to stay home.

Maria said...

You (as in you in general, not you specifically) can find guilt over anything if you choose to. I think finding the joy is much harder, because we worry about how it might look to others. As long as people are happy and things work well for them, everyone else should be happy about their choices too. (I have a friend who wants to be a working mom but she feels too guilty to go to work because she thinks she's supposed to stay home and be happy about it. I think I'll suggest this book to her!)

Cynthia said...

Adding it to my list, thanks!
The worst comment I heard was (while pregnant with the Littlest One) "if you're not going to stay home with him, why are you having another one?"
Really?
A happy and supportive mother is the best mother. You are a fine example :-)
Side note: even if I did stay home, I wouldn't make homemade things for school functions because even the smallest children are smart enough to not want what I've baked!

The Adventures of Carrie, Brook, Finn and Reid said...

Now I'm anxious to read this book! I ordered this on PBS after several recommendations and it will hopefully be in my mailbox SOON!

Right now, I am the only one in my (local) group of friends who has two kids in daycare and works full-time. It's getting easier to explain my decision (although, really, why do I have to?) as the boys get older, but its tough not having any close friends who can relate and give (mutual) reassurance on those tough days when you really need it!

The past couple of months have been tough for us illness-wise and have brought me back to the first 2 years of (group) daycare when I rarely made it through a full week at work due to THE CALL from daycare requesting a pick up.

Writing the monthly check for a month or two that your kids are hardly even in attendenence really sucks, but the small fortune that I am spending for 5 years of daycare is worth it. My family is getting a better version of me!

Can't wait to read this book!

Karen said...

I agree with London that there is criticism on both sides. Moms should be able to make the choice that works best for them and their family without feeling any guilt.

Having done both the working and SAH mom thing, I completely agree with you that there are pros and cons to both!

Stacey said...

arrghh... I hear this debate all the time....and really for our family it works best me being a working mom. I did stay home for almost two full years when the twins were young (worked when they were 10months old-13months) and for us personally I find that I have more quality time with them as a working mom. Yes when I stayed home we had more "time" together but I did more during that time as well. The entire debate is also affected by the fact that we have a daycare that they absolutely love.

erinlaughs said...

Amen indeed!

I had/have a lot of that guilt as well, although for me, I"m the only breadwinner so the choice to not work isn't there.

Thank you for reminding me to request the three-year-old book from the library. Friend or enemy indeed!

Kim {LucyJaneStudio} said...

Laura - I'm good friends with Jennifer (Flesworthy) and saw your comment to her post, so being my nosy self I headed over to your blog. I have three year old twins and am WAHM. I struggle with the balance between being home with the boys and trying to run my esty shop.

I've been having a huge internal debate over sending them to school for long days next year. I completely agree that as a society we are expected to be perfect moms! I'll have to check out this book. Glad I found your blog.

Ann said...

"Like" :-)

Steph said...

I have now been on both sides of the fence- worked with Cooper, now I stay at home with both (but mostly Abby with Cooper in preschool). Definitely pros and cons to each choice. I am still new to the SAHM game so its still an adjustment. Right now I couldn't tell you that I prefer one or the other, but each was the right choice for me at the time.

Tanika Davis said...

I agree on so many counts -- especially about not loving the judgment that flies about for either choice a woman makes. I think women should practice being supportive of other women's choices more often. After all, no one really knows what our lives are like but us!
P.S. I still think your blog is better than 90-percent of the parenting books I've read, particularly when it comes to twins. Not even kidding.

Sara said...

LOVE THIS POST!! Can we just please end the judgement and debate between working moms and SAHM's for good!!! I'm so over it. This is 2011, right?? We should support one another as woman and parents raising children. I have done both, full time, part time, and now stay at home mom (for now...) Both are hard and have their own challenges and rewards. I will read this book and pass it on to otheres.I truly enjoy your blog, found it on how do you do it. I have a 3 yr old son and 8 month b/g twins.